The Union outcontrols state factions

Collapse premise

Conclusion

The case for the Union

Show graph for this premise

The Union’s greater size and structure make factious combinations harder to form, coordinate, and spread than within the individual States.

Unknown

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

Unknown by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

Collapse premise

Scale joined to federal design

Show graph for this premise

The Union outcontrols state factions

The Union’s greater size and structure make factious combinations harder to form, coordinate, and spread than within the individual States.

Unknown

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

Unknown by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

is true if

The federal Constitution balances scale

The federal Constitution usefully divides authority by sending great and aggregate interests to the national government and local and particular interests to state legislatures.

Unknown

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

Unknown by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

and

Large republics control faction better

A large republic is more favorable than a small republic for choosing proper representatives and for preventing oppressive faction because it contains more interests, more candidates, and more obstacles to conspiracy.

Needs Support

This claim has no citation and isn't the consequent of any premise.

Unknown

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

Unknown by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

Collapse premise

Vindication of the federal plan

Show graph for this premise

The federal Constitution balances scale

The federal Constitution usefully divides authority by sending great and aggregate interests to the national government and local and particular interests to state legislatures.

Unknown

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

Unknown by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

is true if

The Union checks faction

A well-constructed Union tends to break and control the violence of faction, making it a safeguard against domestic faction and insurrection.

Unknown

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

Unknown by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

and

The Union outcontrols state factions

The Union’s greater size and structure make factious combinations harder to form, coordinate, and spread than within the individual States.

Unknown

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

Unknown by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

Collapse premise

Why a safeguard is needed

Show graph for this premise

The Union checks faction

A well-constructed Union tends to break and control the violence of faction, making it a safeguard against domestic faction and insurrection.

Unknown

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

Unknown by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

is true if

Majority factions can oppress

When a faction includes a majority, popular government can let it sacrifice the public good and others’ rights to its ruling passion or interest.

Unknown

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

Unknown by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

and

Faction ruins popular government

Instability, injustice, and confusion are the mortal diseases under which popular governments have perished, and faction drives those harms.

Needs Support

This claim has no citation and isn't the consequent of any premise.

Unknown

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

Unknown by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

Collapse premise

Interested judges of their own cause

Show graph for this premise

Majority factions can oppress

When a faction includes a majority, popular government can let it sacrifice the public good and others’ rights to its ruling passion or interest.

Unknown

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

Unknown by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

is true if

Self-interest biases judgment

A person cannot be a judge in his own cause because interest biases judgment and may corrupt integrity; the same problem applies even more strongly to legislative bodies deciding on classes that include their own members.

True

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

True by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

and

Property creates interests

Unequal distribution of property creates distinct interests and parties, and regulating those interests is a principal task of modern legislation.

Needs Support

This claim has no citation and isn't the consequent of any premise.

Unknown

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

Unknown by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

Collapse premise

Representation scaled up

Show graph for this premise

The Union outcontrols state factions

The Union’s greater size and structure make factious combinations harder to form, coordinate, and spread than within the individual States.

Unknown

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

Unknown by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

is true if

Republics can cure faction

A republic, which uses representation, offers a cure for faction that a pure democracy lacks.

Unknown → True

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

This is unknown by default; the evaluator inferred true from surrounding decisions. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

and

Large republics control faction better

A large republic is more favorable than a small republic for choosing proper representatives and for preventing oppressive faction because it contains more interests, more candidates, and more obstacles to conspiracy.

Needs Support

This claim has no citation and isn't the consequent of any premise.

Unknown

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

Unknown by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

Collapse premise

From assembly to representation

Show graph for this premise

Republics can cure faction

A republic, which uses representation, offers a cure for faction that a pure democracy lacks.

Unknown → True

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

This is unknown by default; the evaluator inferred true from surrounding decisions. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

is true if

Pure democracy cannot cure faction

A pure democracy, with citizens assembling and governing in person, can admit no cure for faction and is prone to turbulence, contention, insecurity, and property violations.

True

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

True by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

Collapse premise

Controlling effects, not causes

Show graph for this premise

Republics can cure faction

A republic, which uses representation, offers a cure for faction that a pure democracy lacks.

Unknown → True

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

This is unknown by default; the evaluator inferred true from surrounding decisions. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

is true if

Liberty cannot be removed

Destroying liberty would be a worse remedy than the disease, because liberty is essential to political life even though it nourishes faction.

True

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

True by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

and

Faction has two remedies

The mischiefs of faction can be cured only by removing its causes or by controlling its effects.

Unknown → True

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

This is unknown by default; the evaluator inferred true from surrounding decisions. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

Collapse premise

Two paths from an incurable cause

Show graph for this premise

Faction has two remedies

The mischiefs of faction can be cured only by removing its causes or by controlling its effects.

Unknown → True

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

This is unknown by default; the evaluator inferred true from surrounding decisions. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

is true if

Faction arises from human nature

The latent causes of faction are sown in human nature and are activated by religion, politics, leadership rivalries, and unequal property.

Unknown → True

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

This is unknown by default; the evaluator inferred true from surrounding decisions. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

Collapse premise

No cure by making men alike

Show graph for this premise

Faction arises from human nature

The latent causes of faction are sown in human nature and are activated by religion, politics, leadership rivalries, and unequal property.

Unknown → True

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

This is unknown by default; the evaluator inferred true from surrounding decisions. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

is true if

Uniform opinion is impossible

It is impracticable to make every citizen hold the same opinions, passions, and interests, because human reason is fallible and unequal property interests arise naturally.

True

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

True by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

Collapse premise

From definition to origin

Show graph for this premise

Faction arises from human nature

The latent causes of faction are sown in human nature and are activated by religion, politics, leadership rivalries, and unequal property.

Unknown → True

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

This is unknown by default; the evaluator inferred true from surrounding decisions. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

is true if

Faction serves adverse interests

A faction is a group of citizens, majorities or minorities, united by passion or interest adverse to the rights of others or the community’s permanent aggregate interests.

True

Default — derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown.

True by default — not your assignment. Derived from how this claim is used: grounded claims (citations, axioms, and claims they directly support) start true; claims the argument still has to reach start unknown. Click to edit.

Source

Sign in to vote

The Union outcontrols state factions

About this source

About: Federalist No. 10

The Union outcontrols state factions

About this source

About: Federalist No. 10